Shopify vs Etsy vs Squarespace: Which is Best

Among the top eCommerce websites, Shopify, Etsy, and Squarespace are always at the forefront. They are popular, famous, and boast massive user bases. So, what makes them special? This article compares Shopify vs Etsy vs Squarespace in terms of features, pricing, and suitability to help you decide.

Shopify vs Etsy vs Squarespace: An Overview

In the world of online business, you’ve probably heard these names thrown around a lot: Shopify, Etsy, and Squarespace. These websites collectively have millions of businesses worldwide. Shopify hosts over 4.5 million active stores worldwide, while Etsy unites 9 million sellers with 96 million buyers. And Squarespace is home to 4.8 million sites.

Shopify is a paid online store builder that has been around since 2006. As a fully hosted, cloud-based solution, Shopify provides a one-for-all commerce platform. You can use the platform to sell both online and in person. It is super user-friendly and has a robust ecosystem and feature suite that make it easy to start with.

Etsy is an internet marketplace for creative sector sellers. It is more about giving a simple means to showcase your craft to a like-minded community. Here, independent makers, DIY crafters, and collectors get all the necessary tools and documentaries to open a virtual store and sell handmade and unique items.

Squarespace is a website builder that offers a fully hosted solution to create an online shop. The service offers merchants everything they need to start selling online, including themes, marketing features built into the service, and secure payments. The drag-and-drop function makes Squarespace very simple to use for non-technical users.

Let’s now examine the specific details of each platform.

Shopify: The E-commerce Powerhouse

The history of Shopify starts with a small group of founders in Ottawa, Canada. Led by Tobias Lutke, Shopify was initially a snowboard store. Noticing the lack of user-friendly e-commerce solutions at the time, the team decided to shift their focus to building a simplified online selling platform from scratch.

And their vision has proven to be true. As of now, Shopify has over 4.5 million active stores across the world. The platform dominates the U.S. e-commerce software market with a 29% share and contributes $444 billion to global economic activity annually.

As a Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) solution, Shopify features everything needed to build online stores. The dashboard offers unlimited product listings, inventory management, order tracking, and customer data analytics. Adding to that are solid in-built tools for SEO optimization, marketing automation, and secure payment processing.

What makes Shopify an e-commerce powerhouse is its scalability and robust ecosystem. Its app store of over 8,000 integrations makes it even easier to start selling online. Among notable tools are one-click integration with Google Analytics and automated tools for product import and export. Merchants can also connect with their customers via various platforms and marketplaces, be it Instagram and TikTok or Amazon or Etsy.

However, a custom domain name is not covered on Shopify plans. If you want to get rid of the default .myshopify.com subdomain, you will need to buy a new domain through Shopify or connect an existing one. Domain prices through Shopify typically range from $10 to over $30 per year.

There are also transaction costs for payments processed through third-party gateways (e.g., PayPal, Stripe). The amount is up to 2% on the Basic plan.

Pros

• Highly scalable with plans for small to enterprise-level businesses
• Extensive app store for customization
• Multi-channel selling (social media, marketplaces)
• Advanced analytics and abandoned cart recovery

Cons

• Transaction fees apply unless using Shopify Payments (0.5%-2% extra)
• Advanced features require higher-tier plans or paid apps
• Less focus on design compared to Squarespace

Pricing: 3 months for $1, then $25/month for the basics.

Best for: All business sizes. Everyone from solo entrepreneurs to global brands can use Shopify.

💡 Shopify is currently running the 3 MONTHS FOR JUST $1 program, which allows new and aspiring entrepreneur to open their online store & start earning without the fear of high initial cost. This is the best chance to test out your business idea!

Etsy: The Artisan’s Marketplace

Etsy is not a regular marketplace; it’s dedicated to creators and collectors alike. Established in 2005, the platform has been connecting artisans with buyers seeking handmade, vintage, and craft goods and never wavered from its mission to “keep commerce human.”

Currently, Etsy boasts 8.52 million active sellers and 96.71 million active buyers in the U.S. and beyond. It is ranked as the 9th most popular platform for holiday gift shopping in the U.S. in 2024, trailing giants like Amazon but leading in its niche of unique, artisanal products.

Setting up a virtual storefront on Etsy is simple. To start selling, all you need to do is to list the items and provide details for store name and images, which can be done within a few steps. Extensive setup for themes, coding, or hosting is unnecessary since the platform is ready-made.

Etsy provides merchants with various tools. The intuitive Shop Manager dashboard consolidates listing creation, order tracking, and customer messaging in one place. Other in-built tools are analytics dashboards, inventory management, and promotional options like Etsy Ads and coupon codes.

Comparing Etsy vs Shopify vs Squarespace is like comparing apples and oranges, because one is niche-focused and others are more broadly adaptable. However, when talking about selling similar categories, Etsy’s built-in buyer base gives it an edge for quick starts. The platform has a strong and engaged user base, who value uniqueness and craftsmanship. Such discerning shoppers are likely to buy when it comes to one-of-a-kind items. In fact, 40% of Etsy customers are repeat buyers.

On the other hand, Etsy offers limited options for customization and branding, even with its Etsy Plus. Options like shop banners and featured listings exist, but you can’t fully redesign your storefront. That means it takes more effort to have an edge over other sellers. Furthermore, while the platform is free, it does come with additional fees, which can eat up to 15-20% of revenue.

Pros

• Built-in audience of millions of buyers
• Low upfront costs (no monthly subscription)
• Simple setup for beginners
• Strong community and niche focus

Cons

• Limited customization and branding control
• High fees per sale (6.5% transaction + 20¢ listing fee + payment processing)
• Less scalability for growing beyond the marketplace
• Competition from other sellers within the platform

Pricing: No monthly fee, $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing (U.S.). The Etsy Plus plan starts at $1/month.

Best for: Artists and niche sellers can benefit the most from Etsy.

Squarespace: The Design-Centric Platform

Squarespace is more about looks and seamless user experience. The platform was created in 2003, with the mission being to empower anyone to build a beautiful online presence without technical expertise. Its founder, Anthony Casalena, started it as a solo project in his University of Maryland dorm room, aiming to simplify website creation.

In the e-commerce and website builder space, Squarespace stands among the top players, ranking fourth in the U.S. CMS market with a 2-3% share and holding a global footprint with over 4.8 million live websites worldwide.

How Squarespace works is that it offers an all-in-one, hosted solution for building websites with e-commerce capabilities. To begin with, you choose from over 185 professionally designed templates, customize them using a drag-and-drop editor, and launch your site.

Moving to the features, Squarespace has integrated tools like inventory management, blogging, email marketing, and Squarespace AI for generating text or layouts. Within the interface is a clean, intuitive dashboard that centralizes design adjustments, analytics, and store management. Built-in integrations also cover social media (e.g., Instagram Shopping), payments (Stripe, PayPal, Square), and basic analytics (Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel).

Comparing Shopify vs Squarespace, the latter one is more modest in scope since its focus is on simplicity and ease of use. Squarespace does offer extensions and add-ons from third parties, but the numbers are limited. Native multi-channel syncing is also restricted to basic options like SKU IQ for Square.

In addition to that, Squarespace charges a little fee for payments processed through third-party gateways such as Stripe or PayPal on the Business plan. The amount is around 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction.

Pros

• Beautiful, customizable templates
• Intuitive interface, great for beginners
• All-in-one platform (no need for extra apps initially)
• Strong blogging and content marketing tools

Cons

• Limited scalability for large e-commerce operations
• Fewer advanced e-commerce features compared to Shopify
• Transaction fees on lower plans (3% on Business plan)
• Less robust multi-channel selling options

Pricing: Business plan starts at $14/month and $10/month for personal use (no e-commerce).

Best for: Small to medium businesses, creatives, or service providers who emphasize design, simplicity, and content-driven marketing over complex e-commerce needs can use Squarespace.

Shopify vs Squarespace vs Etsy: A Comparison Guide

As evident from the overviews above, the differences between Shopify vs Etsy vs Squarespace are pretty stark depending on your goals. One is a scalable e-commerce giant, another thrives as a niche artisan marketplace, and the latter is a design-driven all-in-one solution.

The following table will summarize their strengths, weaknesses, and key features to help you decide which fits your needs best.

Verdict: Which One Is The Best For Your Store?

So, with the Shopify vs Etsy vs Squarespace comparisons laid out, we would like to rank Shopify as the best platform. While pricier to start with, it has an unbeatable deal at only $1 for 3 months, so its overall value shines through. Etsy comes in as the most affordable upfront with no monthly fee, but be aware of its high per-sale charges. And Squarespace is just a few dollars away, which is a steal for its design quality.

But considering special needs, here are our final takeaways:

• Choose Shopify if you need a scalable, feature-rich e-commerce platform for multi-channel selling and growth with a robust app ecosystem.
• Choose Etsy if you’re an artisan or small seller wanting a low-barrier entry to a built-in marketplace audience for handmade or niche goods.
• Choose Squarespace if you prioritize stunning design and simplicity.

Find our content helpful? Visit BSS Commerce for more insightful comparisons!

• Facebook
• Twitter
• LinkedIn
• Pinterest